↓Skip to main content
Zeitgeist — a spike by Chris Gathercole
  1. Creators/
  2. Sarah C. M. Paine — Naval War College/

How Trump and Putin Destroy the Power They Claim to Restore | Sarah Paine

YouTube · Guest appearance on Pyotr Kurzin | Geopolitics · Watch/Read

  • The core argument distinguishes between tactical/operational success and strategic failure, asserting that true success is only measurable at the strategic level, which considers long-term consequences and broader geopolitical implications.
  • Sarah Paine introduces the “tactical, operational, and strategic level” framework, explaining that while actions like the capture of Maduro might be operationally brilliant, they can be strategic disasters by alienating allies and eroding the rules-based international order.
  • A critical warning is issued against reverting to a “continental paradigm” (focused on territorial acquisition and unilateral action) over the post-WWII “maritime security strategy” (focused on alliances, trade, and institutions), as the former is negative-sum, leads to endless conflict, and dangerously increases the risk of hot wars in a nuclear era.